Star Trek: “Tomorrow is Yesterday” Review

“I never have believed in little green men.”

I’m afraid I’ve gotten quite far behind on this re-watch! Last night I watched “Tomorrow is Yesterday”. This was the 22nd episode to be produced and the 19th to air. It first aired on January 26, 1967. This episode was written by DC Fontana.

Story

Is it a coherent story?

The Enterprise finds itself back in time – Earth in 1969. The ship is spotted by the US Air Force as a UFO and the crew must find a way to erase knowledge of their visit, and a way to return to the 23rd century. 5/5

Is it enjoyable to watch?

This episode is generally quite enjoyable. It’s great fun to see the Enterprise in Earth’s orbit being pursued by 20th century aircraft. Viewers must have wondered whether they were watching the right show when it first aired because it opens with scenes of military stock footage rather than anything Trek-like. I’m less engaged by the planet-side scenes but it’s still entertaining. 4/5

Is the dialogue strong and/or memorable?

The dialogue is strongest for Spock and McCoy. Fontana really liked that relationship and this episode does a lot to embed their frenemy status in our minds. There’s a moment when Spock admits to making an error in computations and McCoy says, “Oh? This could be an historic occasion.” There’s another moment where Kirk says McCoy is sounding like Spock and McCoy says, “If you’re going to get nasty, I’m going to leave.”

Later, when Kirk is briefly on the surface and out of contact with the ship, McCoy gets frustrated with Spock and says, “Blast your theories and observations, Mr. Spock!” which is a line I always remember. 4/5

Does it serve the main cast well?

Spock and McCoy are the highlights here. Kirk does get some action scenes that are mostly unnecessary to the story but must have kept Shatner happy. Sulu gets to beam to the surface with Kirk and it’s good to see him get something to do. It is odd that Kirk and Sulu beam to Earth in their uniforms. You’d think they’d try to disguise themselves in something from the 20th century. Kirk also gives the colonel his real name when questioned which seems ill-advised.

A highlight of this episode is Kirk meeting a kind of counterpart of his from the past. Captain Christopher represents a similar heroic figure. What might Christopher have accomplished had he been born in the 23rd century rather than the 20th? 4/5

If there are guest or recurring characters, are they memorable or interesting?

Captain John Christopher is an interesting character. For a generation who lived through (and served in) WWII, these kinds of military figures held an heroic status. He’s the first in a series of pilots and astronauts that we see in flashbacks across the various Trek series. They form a fictional history of the space program that leads to Starfleet.

This is John Winston’s first appearance as Kyle. That character will go on to appear in several episodes of TOS and in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. 4/5

World-building

Does it contribute positively to the Trek Universe?

We briefly learn that time travel is possible in “The Naked Time” but this is the first episode that really explores it. Time travel stories become a staple of Trek and make for some of the most memorable episodes. In particular, we’ll see the slingshot method of time travel again in some key stories. 5/5

Is it consistent with the rest of canon?

We get a mention of the United Earth Space Probe Agency which we’ve heard before. We also hear “Starfleet Control” which I think is unique to this episode, but clearly getting closer to the standard Starfleet Command. We learn that a tractor beam can be dangerous to vessels that are not built with Starfleet-level technology. I didn’t catch any anachronisms. 5/5

Is there something new and unique?

This is the first time we travel back to Earth of the past. Trek will do this many times in the future but here it’s unique. 4/5

Does the science seem plausible?

It’s a black star that drags the Enterprise towards it, causing a breakaway that sends the ship back through time and a distance through space. I believe a black star is a theoretical possibility but I don’t recall ever reading about one actually being discovered. I’m really not sure if one would do what is posited here but it seems possible enough to a layman like myself. 4/5

Production

Production design (sets, props)

Time travel episodes to the past are clever because they mean production can make use of sets, props, and costumes that are all readily available. We see some wonderful photographic equipment and recording equipment at the military base. Kirk has a pretty nifty flashlight when he and Sulu beam down to the base. 4/5

Costumes

I’m told that not all the military uniforms and insignia are correct but I didn’t notice. When Captain Christopher is given a Starfleet uniform tunic to wear, the rank is for lieutenant which I gather is the equivalent of his Air Force captain’s rank. We’ve seen McCoy in his short-sleeved surgical tunic before but it stood out to me in this episode. When Kirk is in a very energetic fight on the surface, his boots make a lot of scuff marks on the set. This is something we see several times but it’s especially noticeable in this episode. 4/5

Make-up and Hair

The only thing I noted here is that Uhura seems to be having a bad hair day. 3/5

Visual Effects

I already mentioned the footage of the Enterprise flying through Earth’s cloudy sky. This was cool in the original episode but drastically improved in the remastered version. The slingshot effect also looks terrific in the remastered version. 5/5

Music

The music for this episode was written by Alexander Courage, but I believe I also heard some of Fred Steiner’s score from “The Corbomite Maneuver”. 4/5

Acting (series regulars and guests)

The regulars are all great in this episode. Roger Perry is strong as Captain Christopher. My favourite performance in this episode might be from Hal Lynch as the Air Police sergeant who gets accidentally beamed up to the Enterprise. It’s a huge challenge to realistically play a reaction to being transported from a 20th century environment to the 23rd and he does a good job with it. It is, nevertheless, a bit goofy. I love when Kyle asks if he wants something to eat and the sergeant replies, “maybe some chicken soup”. There’s just something about the line delivery that tickles me. 5/5

Direction (coherent, memorable)

This episode was directed by Michael O’Herlihy. I believe this was his only Trek outing. He had an interesting challenge to deal with integrating stock footage into the episode. There are some continuity errors in the sky sequences and with Captain Christopher’s costume accessories but the remastered edition fixes most of the sky problems and the costume continuity is only really noticeable on close re-watchings. I wish they had paused to fix Uhura’s hair. 3/5

Philosophy

Is it thought-provoking?

Time travel paradoxes are always interesting to ponder. Here, Spock initially says that Captain Christopher should stay aboard the Enterprise because he finds no record of “relevant contributions” made by Christopher, meaning history wouldn’t miss him. Later, he digs deeper and discovers that Christopher will have a son who will be part of a key mission to Saturn. This is why future Trek time travel stories will almost never consider leaving or taking someone out of their time. There are just too many variables. 5/5

Does it deal with a moral or ethical issue?

The only thing that comes up for me here is that the Enterprise crew really hold Captain Christopher’s fate in their hands and don’t give him much agency. It’s Kirk’s fault that Christopher’s plane is destroyed and I don’t think he ever apologizes for it. Then, until Spock finds out about Christoher’s son, Kirk decides he’s just going to keep Christopher aboard. Sure, he’s doing it to protect the timeline but I think I would have tried to have a discussion about it and let Christopher come to the logical conclusion on his own. 2/5

Is it consistent with Trek’s optimism and Humanism?

Yes. I mentioned Trek’s fictional history of spaceflight. The Apollo 11 mission in July 1969 was right around the corner when this episode was produced. It must have been a very exciting time. We also get the mention of the mission to Saturn. These first forays into our solar system are the beginnings of exploring the final frontier. Roddenberry’s concept that Humanity would eventually mature enough to go out into space and interact with other species is the core of Star Trek’s optimistic vision of the future. 5/5

IDEA (Inclusion, Diversity, Equity, Accessibility)

There is some gender stuff at play in this episode. Christopher is surprised to see women in uniform as part of Kirk’s crew. The more amusing scene is the one where the Enterprise computer (voiced by Majel Barrett since “Mudd’s Women”) is speaking to Kirk in kind of a flirty voice. Kirk tells Christopher that the computer had been serviced on Cygnet XIV, a planet dominated by women. The idea of a planet dominated by women would be explored again in TAS and TNG. 3/5

Conclusion

My ratings for this episode total 81/100, putting it kind of in the middle of the heap for the episodes reviewed thus far.

Leave a Reply